BRUMAIREMANAGEMENT
Perspectives
CAPITAL ALLOCATION

Where you live.
Where capital works.

A home provides a place to live. The financial question is what the same starting capital and monthly budget could become under a different housing decision.

Our fund’s perspective starts with opportunity cost. A down payment is capital that could own productive businesses. A lower housing bill creates room for additional investment. The result depends on turning that room into consistent contributions.

The relevant comparison includes the full ownership outlay, mortgage amortization, rent increases, and the buyer’s later capacity to invest. It also recognizes the value of stability and control that a home can provide.

SCENARIO ANALYSIS · PRE-TAX

Rent & invest. Buy & build equity.

Equal starting capital. Equal monthly budgets.

STARTING CAPITAL, EACH
Invested portfolio or down payment

Explore 7–16% equity total returns and 0–6% home appreciation. These are scenarios, not probabilities or forecasts; outcomes outside this range, including losses, remain possible.

Rent + invest$21.49m

Investment portfolio after 25 years

Buy + invest$4.79m

$4.79m home equity + $0 investments

At 13% equity total return and 4% home appreciation, rent + invest has the higher modeled net worth after 25 years. Both paths include the same housing budget and starting capital.

Both paths use comparable housing of the same size, type, quality, and location. Each household has the same monthly budget, set to the higher housing outlay that month, and invests any amount left after housing. Net worth includes investments and, for the buyer, the home less the outstanding mortgage. Results are before income and capital-gains taxes. Transaction costs and trading fees are excluded. Model details

Illustration: $2.0m home, 20% down, 6% mortgage, 25× price-to-rent ratio, $6,667 starting monthly rent. Property tax is fixed at 0.9% and upkeep, insurance, and HOA at 1% of home value annually. Full assumptions and calculation method are in the research methodology.

A higher-return future

Our upside case rests on the continued concentration of productive capacity. Scale, pricing power, global distribution, and reinvested earnings can reinforce one another. Our fund is designed to participate as that accumulation moves among leading businesses.

Mid-teens returns over 25 years have historical precedent: the reference index compounded at approximately 15.35% annually over 1976–2000, with dividends reinvested. This selected period demonstrates possibility, not the probability of the next 25 years. The 13% and 16% scenarios make that upside case available for examination.

Concentration alone does not determine shareholder returns. Earnings growth and the price paid for those earnings still matter.

The exceptional property

A neighborhood that appreciated twentyfold over 25 years produced approximately 12.7% annualized price growth. That is a remarkable individual outcome. Equity markets have their own outliers, including NVIDIA.

A broad portfolio deserves comparison with a broad market. Individual winners require matching dates and consistent treatment of income, leverage, and costs. Identifying a winner after the fact is different from allocating capital before its success is known.

The discipline of the alternative

Renting preserves investment capital only when the down payment and ongoing savings are actually invested. Spending the difference changes the result. The same principle applies to a buyer’s savings after the mortgage is repaid.

Illustrative analysis, not a forecast or personal recommendation. Model assumptions and methodology