BRUMAIREMANAGEMENT
DISCLOSURES & METHODOLOGY

The basis
of the record.

Performance methodology

The arithmetic average gives equal weight to each year’s return. The compound annual growth rate (CAGR) measures the annual rate that reproduces the final wealth. The rounded 15% and 12% headlines identify their different measures.

S&P 500 total return · periods ending December 31, 2025
PeriodAverageCAGR
2011–202514.98%14.07%
1976–202513.31%12.04%

All equity history includes reinvested dividends. Computed from the rounded annual series published by Slickcharts. The growth charts compound those same returns, assuming reinvested dividends. The historical 1976–2000 example uses the same series and calculates CAGR across those 25 calendar years. Values are nominal and exclude fees and taxes.

Housing research methodology

In the default scenario, each household begins with $400,000. The buyer uses it as a 20% down payment on a $2m home; the renter invests the same amount and rents a comparable home. Starting capital and down payment percentage are adjustable, so the home price equals starting capital divided by the down payment fraction. Both households use housing of the same size, type, quality, and location.

The default mortgage is $1.6m at 6% over 30 years, approximately $9,593 a month. The mortgage rate is adjustable and payments amortize monthly. Home equity is home value less the actual remaining loan balance. Initial annual rent equals home price divided by the adjustable price-to-rent ratio, which defaults to 25. The default monthly rent is $6,667. Rent rises by 35% per decade, applied as an equivalent monthly rate.

Each month, both households receive an identical budget equal to that month’s higher housing outlay. Owner outlay includes the mortgage payment, property tax fixed at 0.9% annually, and upkeep, insurance, and HOA fixed at 1% annually, based on the opening home value. Whoever spends less invests the difference at month-end.

Equity total return and home appreciation are adjustable annual assumptions converted to equivalent monthly growth rates. Dividends are reinvested within equity total return and are not added twice. After payoff, the mortgage payment stops; the buyer invests any resulting advantage. The home provides the buyer’s housing, so no rental income or imputed rent is added to their wealth.

The illustration measures nominal, pretax net worth. It does not calculate income-tax deductions or capital-gains taxes on liquidation. Transaction costs, trading fees, and ongoing fund fees are excluded, as are utilities, moving costs, and extraordinary repairs. Returns and spending are smoothed, so the model does not capture volatility or the sequence of returns. Results can favor either path as assumptions change.

Investment implementation

The implementation is a low-cost fund tracking the S&P 500, with dividends reinvested. Vanguard’s VOO is one example. VOO began in 2010; the 50-year record shown here belongs to the index, not that ETF. “Dynamic” refers to changing market weights and index membership, rather than proprietary allocation or active hedging. No leverage, short selling, or market-timing.

See the index provider’s overview and index methodology. The index is a U.S. large-cap selection subject to eligibility criteria, not simply the 500 largest firms worldwide. Fund fees and tracking differences reduce or alter realized results.

Status and risk

Brumaire Management is a brand and investment-philosophy concept, not an operating hedge fund or an offer to invest. The historical figures are benchmark results, not an audited manager track record. The thesis is an interpretation of economic structure, not a proven law of returns.

Equities can suffer substantial losses, including over long periods. Market-cap weighting creates company and sector concentration. The persistence of corporate profits does not guarantee a positive shareholder return. Past performance does not guarantee future results.

Other asset context

The thesis favors claims on productive earnings. Gold offers a different exposure and can outperform for long stretches. It pays no dividends; its return here is its change in price.

Historical annualized returns through December 31, 2025
PeriodReference index
Dividends reinvested
Gold
15 years14.07%7.81%
25 years8.82%11.68%
50 years12.04%7.11%

Nominal CAGR, before fees, taxes, or storage costs. Gold is one commodity, not the entire asset class. Sources: Slickcharts and Damodaran. The 15-year CAGR differs from the arithmetic average featured above.